A Cinderella Story Awards

Teen Choice Award
For:
Choice Breakout Movie Star - Male: Chad Michael Murray
Year: 2004
Won

Teen Choice Award
For:
Choice Movie Sleazebag- Jennifer Coolidge
Choice Movie Blush Scene- Hilary Duff
Year: 2005
Won

Blimp Award
For:
Favorite Movie Actress- Hilary Duff
Year: 2005
Won